in what movies has Katie Holmes appeared with Gerard Butler

Katie Holmes (born December 18th 1978), the American actress featured in such films as The Ice Storm and Batman Begins is someone who acted in the production which movie (connected cinematic narrative) with Gerard James Butler (born November 13, 1969), the Scottish actor and singer best known to American audiences for his portrayal of King Leonidas in 300 and The Phantom in the 2004 film version of The Phantom of the Opera?

Facts Show facts

Show reasoning Reasoning

I followed this chain of reasoning:

By calculation (generator: ["now@trueknowledge.com"]) I know that:
The current time is May 21st 2013, 20:18:28

I know from locally stored knowledge that:
is someone who acted in is a more general form of is in the cast of the screened production ([fact: ["234459218@trueknowledge.com"]])

permanent applies to is someone who acted in ([fact: ["234459174@trueknowledge.com"]])

is in the cast of the screened production is a more general form of is a star of ([fact: ["123911814@trueknowledge.com"]])

Fact 1: Katie Holmes is a star of Smile ([fact: ["682139408@trueknowledge.com"]])

By calculation (generator: ["perm5@trueknowledge.com"]) I know that:
Fact 1 is true for all time

I know from locally stored knowledge that:
permanent applies to is a star of ([fact: ["123878425@trueknowledge.com"]])

By calculation (generator: ["moregeneral1@trueknowledge.com"]) I know that:
Fact 2: Katie Holmes is in the cast of the screened production Smile

Fact 2 is true for all time

By calculation (generator: ["moregeneral4@trueknowledge.com"]) I know that:
Fact 3: Katie Holmes is someone who acted in Smile

By calculation (generator: ["moregeneral1@trueknowledge.com"]) I know that:
Fact 3 is true for all time

By calculation (generator: ["timeperiodtopoint@trueknowledge.com"]) I know that:
Fact 3 is true at May 21st 2013, 20:18:28

I know from locally stored knowledge that:
Fact 4: Gerard Butler is a star of Smile ([fact: ["682139208@trueknowledge.com"]])

By calculation (generator: ["perm5@trueknowledge.com"]) I know that:
Fact 4 is true for all time

By calculation (generator: ["moregeneral1@trueknowledge.com"]) I know that:
Fact 2: Gerard Butler is in the cast of the screened production Smile

Fact 2 is true for all time

By calculation (generator: ["moregeneral4@trueknowledge.com"]) I know that:
Fact 3: Gerard Butler is someone who acted in Smile

By calculation (generator: ["moregeneral1@trueknowledge.com"]) I know that:
Fact 3 is true for all time

By calculation (generator: ["timeperiodtopoint@trueknowledge.com"]) I know that:
Fact 3 is true at May 21st 2013, 20:18:28

I know from locally stored knowledge that:
Smile is a film ([fact: ["682138844@trueknowledge.com"]])

I used the following facts to provide this answer:

'is someone who acted in' is a more general form of 'is in the cast of the screened production'

agree disagree edit

'is someone who acted in' is permanent

agree disagree edit

'is in the cast of the screened production' is a more general form of 'is a star of'

agree disagree edit

Katie Holmes is a star of Smile

agree disagree edit

Gerard Butler is a star of Smile

agree disagree edit

Smile is a film

agree disagree edit